Authority belongs to God's word — the Qur'an and the authentic Sunnah of His Messenger ﷺ — not to any person or office; every dispute is taken back to them (Qur'an 4:59). There is no clergy and no priesthood: anyone may call on God directly (Qur'an 2:186). Scholars explain the texts and the four schools of law organize that work, but a scholar's word weighs only as much as his evidence.
Who holds authority in it, and how is that authority organized?
None; loose intellectual networks.
None; an individual epistemic stance, not a community.
Varies: papal (Catholic), synodal (Orthodox), congregational (Protestant).
Rabbis (teachers/interpreters); no central religious authority.
Sangha (monastic community); teachers, lamas (Tibetan), roshis (Zen).
No central authority; gurus, swamis, schools (sampradayas).
Granthis read scripture; community decisions via Sangat; no clergy.
Secular state, courts, neutral civic institutions.
Humanist associations (IHEU, American Humanist Association).
Constitutional governments, rule of law, free institutions.
Decentralized; academic, activist, and political networks.
The nation-state, political leaders, cultural institutions.
THE SAME WORDING, PUT TO EVERY WORLDVIEW — EACH ANSWERS IN ITS OWN TERMS, IN ITS STRONGEST FORM
Didn't He Say