The library · Claim file
CLAIM № 09METEOROLOGYSŪRAT AR-RAʿDAligned

Are the drifting clouds truly heavy?

A cloud looks weightless; measured, it carries hundreds of thousands of tonnes of water. The adjective the text selects is 'heavy.'

CLAIM № 09METEOROLOGYSŪRAT AR-RAʿDAligned
Primary source

هُوَ الَّذِي يُرِيكُمُ الْبَرْقَ خَوْفًا وَطَمَعًا وَيُنشِئُ السَّحَابَ الثِّقَالَ

"It is He who shows you lightning, [causing] fear and aspiration, and generates the heavy clouds."

Qur'an 13:12 · trans. Saheeh International

Independent findings

To the eye a cloud drifts as if weightless. Measured, a modest cumulus carries water by the hundreds of tonnes, and a single storm cumulonimbus by the hundreds of thousands — mass metered through radar reflectivity and droplet physics in the twentieth century. Against the appearance of weightlessness, the adjective the verse selects is thiqāl — heavy — and classical exegesis already read it as laden with water (7:57 uses the same description). The stamp covers the physical assertion: the clouds are, in fact, heavy.

[15] Rogers & Yau, A Short Course in Cloud Physics · al-Ṭabarī, Jāmiʿ al-bayān ad 13:12 · Q7:57

PROVENANCE: manuscript → Ḥafṣ transmission → 1924 Cairo edition✓ text unchanged

FULL RECORD — OBJECTION LOG, REVISION HISTORY, COUNTING SHEETS — COMING SOON

© 2026 DIDN'T HE SAY — ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. QUR'ANIC TEXT AND CITED PRIMARY SOURCES BELONG TO THEIR SOURCES.TERMSPRIVACY